ACL management on MacOS Snow Leopard

So I was going to follow the directions at this hint site to prevent Time Machine from doing a full backup again once I updated my MacBook Pro to a bigger drive. After all, I don't want to re-backup the stuff I just restored from my backup! But my attempt slammed to a halt after I type 'fsaclctl' and... uhm... WTF? It isn't in Snow Leopard! And by the time you get to userland the permission to override a "Deny All to All" ACL is dropped even if you su to root... you just can't get there from here unless you can somehow turn off ACL support for the whole filesystem!

Ah, but never fear, the Leopard version of fsaclctl works just fine on Snow Leopard. The question is, which of my half dozen backup drives up in the storage closet or offsite is old enough to have Leopard on it? I was about to get up and go grab one, when I glanced down and... there was the Mac OS Leopard 10.5.2 install DVD, right there, in the pile of disks I'd used to re-image the Mac.

So first thing to do was drill down and find the package. The packages live in '/Volumes/Mac OS X Install DVD/System/Installation/Packages' and the easiest thing to do is 'go to folder' from the Finder 'Go' menu to go there. Then by dragging dropping packages onto the /Developer/Applications/Utilities/PackageMaker utility, I discovered that fsaclctl lives in package "BSD.pkg" in directory /usr/sbin.

The next question is, how do we get the file out of the package? I couldn't drag it out of PackageMaker, PackageMaker simply refused to do so. So I grabbed a utility called 'Pacifist'. I won't claim it's the best utility for doing this because it's simply the first one that came up when I googled, but it allowed me to drop the BSD.pkg onto it, drill down to the file, then drag the file out to a folder on my desktop, from whence I could then put it into ~/bin and use it.

Now, this isn't about the Time Machine hack (BTW, it didn't work -- apparently Time Machine's implementation has changed since Leopard), but, rather, about security. Some folks wonder why MacOS is more secure than Windows. This experience gives you one clue why. There are things you cannot override even if you have full administrative access, once permissions are dropped during the boot process. I suspect that in future releases of Snow Leopard will remove the low-level ioctl that fsaclctl relies on, further securing the system. But it's clear that while Apple doesn't make splashy announcements about security and doesn't have some of the bells and whistles like address space randomization, they're doing some things quite right in the background to keep things secure.

-EG